So, here’s the low down on Amish Built fireplaces. You can get them in four finishes, either Cherry, Oak, white or black. While the cabinets are indeed building by the Amish in Ohio, the electric heating element is man-made in China. Of course, electric heat is usually more luxurious compared to gas, oil or wood heat. To get an unbiased review of the Amish Built fireplace, check out Consumer Reports.